Choosing an editor really comes down to the manuscript’s genre, the target age, and honestly the exact editorial vibe you need. So when someone is comparing Children’s Book Editors in Canada, it can help to think about whether they’ve actually worked with picture books, early readers , or middle-grade fiction. Beyond that, you’ll want to see if they’re strong with pacing, vocabulary choices, overall structure, and that age-appropriate wording that doesn’t feel forced.
A lot of people mess this up by picking an editor mostly on price , not on relevant experience.
So, what qualities would you personally look for when you’re comparing editors for a children’s manuscript?